The Right to Defend Property Rights or
The Canary in the Coal Mine of the Montana Court System
Being poor in Montana is no sin. Yet when Gold originally set out to prosecute the City and County of Missoula et al for taking his property and then not protecting it, he encountered that No Civil attorney in Missoula would assist him with his case. He then went to the Missoula Family Law Self-Help Center in the County building but they specialize in Pro Se family law. Next he went to the Montana Legal Services Association who wouldn’t help. He then contacted the Montana ACLU, who wouldn’t help. This was his personal experience which wasted 100’s of his hours, searching. Finally, he was forced to file his own Pro Se cause (and study and learn law himself) even though Montana’s Rules of Professional Conduct in PREAMBLE: A LAWYER'S RESPONSIBILITIES state:
“(7) As a public citizen, a lawyer should seek improvement of the law, access to the legal system, the administration of justice and the quality of service rendered by the legal profession. As a member of a learned profession, a lawyer should cultivate knowledge of the law beyond its use for clients, employ that knowledge in reform of the law and work to strengthen legal education. In addition, a lawyer should further the public’s understanding of and confidence in the rule of law and the justice system because legal institutions in a constitutional democracy depend on popular participation and support to maintain their authority. A lawyer should be mindful of deficiencies in the administration of justice and of the fact that the poor, and sometimes persons who are not poor, cannot afford adequate legal assistance. Therefore, all lawyers should devote professional time and resources and use civic influence to ensure equal access to our system of justice for all those who because of economic or social barriers cannot afford or secure adequate legal counsel. A lawyer should aid the legal profession in pursuing these objectives and should help the bar regulate itself in the public interest.”
So Whose Responsibility is it to Defend the Fundamental Rights of ALL Montanans, including indigents? Certainly, The Montana Public Defender System is a start. All Lawyers Professional Responsibility is a start. The Montana Justices Professional Responsibility is a start. The Montana Court System is a start. The Montana ACLU is a start. The Montana Legal Services Association is a start. The Missoula Family Law Self-Help Center is a start. Taken ALL together, they are ONLY piecemeal parts of the answer to a system that doesn’t work in my cause. And, they are ONLY a start. My cause before you, is an indicator of how that start isn’t working. What it indicates is “the weakest link” in Defending the Fundamental Rights or Civil Liberties Guaranteed in Montana’s Constitution.
Of course, "Defense" attorneys will argue that ALL of these services are underfunded and overwhelmed by the ever increasing needy, and that Defending Our Fundamental Rights (Civil Liberties) takes a VERY back seat to Defending Montanans accused of crimes against the State. And the statistics clearly speak for themselves.
However, this argument is short sighted and completely ignores the most compelling sentence of Art. II § 3 of Montana’s Constitution. “In enjoying these Rights, ALL persons recognize corresponding responsibilities.” ALL people. All Lawyers. All Judges. All Legislators. All Governors. All Politicians. All Counties. All Cities and All Everyday Montanans. ALL persons. But, who monitors or champions or recognizes the importance of these Responsibilities, with an eye to the ever increasing number of poor people in Montana, who are 100 times more likely to have a fundamental rights issue with the state and who ultimately, may have a dire need of Counsel in protecting Every Montanans fundamental rights.
And make NO mistake. These Fundamental Rights are Civil Rights not Criminal. And, those Responsibilities were put there specifically to remind us ALL our "duty to defend" those inalienable rights and especially for those whose duty of care and oath of office make it imperative that they act to support, protect and defend Our Constitution and ALL our Rights.
If you want to keep up with this case and/or read these important briefs:
On the internet goto:
http://fnweb1.isd.doa.state.mt.us/idmws/custom/sll/SLL_FN_Home.htm
Click on: Supreme Court Case Number
Enter either ( DA 09-0675 ) in the box and click search; or Click on: Party search name and enter Gold;
Next click on Gold v. State and then click on
Appelant Brief first then the 2 other briefs and a new windows will pop up with pdfs which you can save and read.
As always, Think about this and I'd like to encourage your comments about this important topic. Feel free to follow this important Case.
Rick Gold
Missoula, MT
Showing posts with label indigence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label indigence. Show all posts
Friday, April 2, 2010
Wednesday, February 3, 2010
The MT Public Defenders and Montana's LESS than poor legal representation.
In the Wednesday February 3, 2010, Missoulian newspaper is an article from Jennifer McKee, of the Missoulian State Bureau entitled "State public defender offices faces $990K cut in addition to current shortfall."
In her article, she writes: "Already facing an $800,000 budget hole, the state agency that guarantees lawyers for poor people accused of crimes could be looking at cutting close to another million dollars from its books."
"How do you cut a million and then cut another million?" "Office of Public Defender administrative director Harry Freebourn said Tuesday of the potential cuts called for by a worsening state budget picture. Freebourn said he had no idea how the agency could absorb another hit, especially considering that its caseload is growing at anywhere between 4 percent and 7 percent."
http://www.missoulian.com/news/state-and-regional/article_72bb5de0-1075-11df-917a-001cc4c002e0.html
However, the Montana Constitution does NOT set a price tag on defense of the poor.
It has been a long standing tradition in the U.S. and the State of Montana to provide legal counsel for the poor in criminal proceedings. But, as the state budget tightens and the already strapped Public Defenders of Montana are asked to reduce their budgets further, the legal representation of the poor can only suffer.
And, therefore once again for the poor, "equal access" of and to the law in Montana (Section 16. The administration of justice) and "equal protection" of and to the law in Montana (Section 4. Individual dignity)
will suffer more than it already has suffered. And, who is speaking for the poor in Montana, who have NO voice in why the Public Defenders budget is being cut!
Now, contrast this with the Montana Attorney General's Budget, and/or the local Montana County/City public Prosecutors (Attorneys) budgets, and you'll soon see that there is NO comparison!
Consequently, there is NO "equal access" or "equal protection" in our Montana Court System.
As always, Think about this and I'd like to encourage your comments about this important topic. Feel free to ask your elected officials.
Rick Gold
Missoula, MT
In her article, she writes: "Already facing an $800,000 budget hole, the state agency that guarantees lawyers for poor people accused of crimes could be looking at cutting close to another million dollars from its books."
"How do you cut a million and then cut another million?" "Office of Public Defender administrative director Harry Freebourn said Tuesday of the potential cuts called for by a worsening state budget picture. Freebourn said he had no idea how the agency could absorb another hit, especially considering that its caseload is growing at anywhere between 4 percent and 7 percent."
http://www.missoulian.com/news/state-and-regional/article_72bb5de0-1075-11df-917a-001cc4c002e0.html
However, the Montana Constitution does NOT set a price tag on defense of the poor.
It has been a long standing tradition in the U.S. and the State of Montana to provide legal counsel for the poor in criminal proceedings. But, as the state budget tightens and the already strapped Public Defenders of Montana are asked to reduce their budgets further, the legal representation of the poor can only suffer.
And, therefore once again for the poor, "equal access" of and to the law in Montana (Section 16. The administration of justice) and "equal protection" of and to the law in Montana (Section 4. Individual dignity)
will suffer more than it already has suffered. And, who is speaking for the poor in Montana, who have NO voice in why the Public Defenders budget is being cut!
Now, contrast this with the Montana Attorney General's Budget, and/or the local Montana County/City public Prosecutors (Attorneys) budgets, and you'll soon see that there is NO comparison!
Consequently, there is NO "equal access" or "equal protection" in our Montana Court System.
As always, Think about this and I'd like to encourage your comments about this important topic. Feel free to ask your elected officials.
Rick Gold
Missoula, MT
Monday, June 8, 2009
Defending our lives, civil liberties & civil rights in Montana and beyond.
In Montana and the United States, in 2009 we are faced with crisis and denial of conscience. What exactly does defending our lives and liberties mean? How do we as human beings and citizens, re-invigorate the principles, rights and responsibilities entrusted to our care and defense in our Constitutions. Why are so much of Montana's and U.S. resources tied up in criminal defense alone. (ex. Google: public defender) Why?
Under The Montana Public Defender Act, the Office of the State Public Defender was formed. "The mission of the Office of the State Public Defender is to ensure equal access to justice for the State's indigent and to provide appellate representation to indigent clients." Note that while the State Public Defender Office mission does NOT specifically exclude Civil causes by their established definition, Public Defenders are mearly "attorneys appointed by a court or employed by the government to represent indigent defendants in criminal actions." Who limited or limits Public Defenders to criminal cases only? Why?
Surely, this is NOT what our founding fathers (and mothers) had in mind when they entreated each and every one of us to defend our lives and civil liberties. And exactly, how do indigent people go about defending their lives and civil liberties against all forms of encroachment by our Montana and U.S. government if they have NO access to a skilled Civil attorney (see equal access, due process and poverty below)? Again why?
The main remedy in Montana provided for the defense of our Civil Liberties is in a Court of Justice. In Montana's Constitution, Article ll - Section 16. The administration of justice. Courts of justice shall be open to every person, and speedy remedy afforded for every injury of person, property, or character… Right and justice shall be administered without sale, denial, or delay.
Think about it ....
As always, please let me have your comments on this important topic, thanks ...
Under The Montana Public Defender Act, the Office of the State Public Defender was formed. "The mission of the Office of the State Public Defender is to ensure equal access to justice for the State's indigent and to provide appellate representation to indigent clients." Note that while the State Public Defender Office mission does NOT specifically exclude Civil causes by their established definition, Public Defenders are mearly "attorneys appointed by a court or employed by the government to represent indigent defendants in criminal actions." Who limited or limits Public Defenders to criminal cases only? Why?
Surely, this is NOT what our founding fathers (and mothers) had in mind when they entreated each and every one of us to defend our lives and civil liberties. And exactly, how do indigent people go about defending their lives and civil liberties against all forms of encroachment by our Montana and U.S. government if they have NO access to a skilled Civil attorney (see equal access, due process and poverty below)? Again why?
The main remedy in Montana provided for the defense of our Civil Liberties is in a Court of Justice. In Montana's Constitution, Article ll - Section 16. The administration of justice. Courts of justice shall be open to every person, and speedy remedy afforded for every injury of person, property, or character… Right and justice shall be administered without sale, denial, or delay.
Think about it ....
As always, please let me have your comments on this important topic, thanks ...
Tuesday, May 19, 2009
poverty vs. indigence in Montana's Public Defender System
In Montana, are the 14.1% statewide poor people (in poverty)? Or are we really, really destitute (indigent)? Because if we are really, really destitute (indigent) then we may be entitled under the new Public Defender Act to equal access to justice and an attorney to boot! A Montanan can NOT simply be in poverty or poor or at a place that they can not afford a $150/hr attorney when the average Montanan's wage is $6.90/hr. No! They must be indigent! Because, "The mission of the Office of the State Public Defender is to ensure equal access to justice for the State's indigent and to provide appellate representation to indigent clients (ONLY!). (http://publicdefender.mt.gov/)
Merriam-Webster's Online Dictionary Defines indigence as: "a level of poverty in which real hardship and deprivation are suffered and comforts of life are wholly lacking." And again, Merriam-Webster's Online Dictionary defines poverty as:"the state of one who lacks a usual or socially acceptable amount of money or material possessions."
So, what does it take to be in real poverty in Montana. In 2009, the U.S. Dept of Human Services says that a person is in realitive poverty if that person makes $10,830 or less per year. See http://aspe.hhs.gov/poverty/09poverty.shtml
While the Small Area Income & Poverty Estimates (SAIPE) for 2007 of the U.S. Census Bureau (http://www.census.gov/) - States: The number of all ages in poverty was 131,433 or 14.1% of Montana's overall population. And for Missoula County, the Missoula City-County Health Department and the Healthy Start Council Sept 3, 2008 Missoulian News: "Seventeen percent of all Montana children age 18 and under live in poverty. However, 38 percent of Native American children 18 and under live in poverty in our state. Yet, Native Americans are only 6 percent of our total population. Sixteen percent of children in Missoula County 18 and under live in poverty. Missoula County ranks 20th in the state, which means 36 counties have even more children living in poverty. The lowest rate is 9 percent in Stillwater County and the highest is 33 percent in Roosevelt County. The number of children in extreme poverty - those living at 50 percent of the federal poverty level - is increasing and has reached a statewide level of 8 percent."
So, what does it take in Montana to be labeled indigent? The U.S. Dept of Human Services or the Census Bureau or the U.S. Government have no relative indicators or charts for indigents. Only from the Montana State Code Section 47-1-104(3) of The Public Defender Act, do we get: "An applicant is indigent if: (a) the applicant's gross household income, as defined in 15-30-171, is at or less than 133% of the poverty level set according to the most current federal poverty guidelines updated periodically in the federal register by the United States department of health and human services under the authority of 42 U.S.C. 9902(2); or (b) the disposable income and assets of the applicant and the members of the applicant's household are insufficient to retain competent private counsel without substantial hardship to the applicant or the members of the applicant's household."
Ask yourself, why would Montana's Legislature and Governor choose to use indigent in the Montana Public Defender Act? Will this discrimination provide more poor Montanans with equal access to our Courts or justice? And exactly what percentage of the 14.1% of those stricken by real poverty will the Court or the Public Defender label indigent and actually try to help? Where have the integrity and the dignity in our Legislature & Governor & Courts gone? Really, what social condition is more acute in 2009 than realitive or real poverty?
Remember, the Montana Constitution's Section 4. Individual dignity. "The dignity of the human being is inviolable. No person shall be denied the equal protection of the laws. Neither the state nor any person, firm, corporation, or institution shall discriminate against any person in the exercise of his civil or political rights on account of race, color, sex, culture, social origin or condition, or political or religious ideas."
In the 1972 Montana Constitutional Convention, Delegate Mrs. Mansfield had these comments regarding Section 4 of the Montana Bill of Rights. "The committee unanimously adopted this section with the intent of providing a constitutional impetus for the eradication of public and private discrimination based on race, color, sex, culture, social origin or condition, or political or religious ideas. The provision, quite similar to that of the Puerto Rico declaration of rights, is aimed at prohibiting private as well as public discrimination in civil and political rights....Social origin or condition was included to cover discriminations based on status of income and standard of living."
And also the comment from Delegate Mr. Dahood, "The intent of Section 4 is simply to provide that every individual in the State of Montana, as a citizen of this state, may pursue his inalienable rights without having any shadows cast upon his dignity through unwarranted discrimination...(C)onstitutions are based on the premise that they are presumed to be self-executing, particularly within the Bill of Rights. If the language appears to be prohibitory and mandatory, as this particular section is intended to be, then in that event, the courts in interpreting the particular section are bound by that particular presumption and they must assume, in that situation, that it is self-executing. There was a case in Montana some 60 years ago that involved a provision of our Bill of Rights that had to do with an individual right, and there the Supreme Court said that was self executing and a citizen could enforce it without any type of legislative implementation."
As always, please let me have your comments on this important topic, thanks ...
Merriam-Webster's Online Dictionary Defines indigence as: "a level of poverty in which real hardship and deprivation are suffered and comforts of life are wholly lacking." And again, Merriam-Webster's Online Dictionary defines poverty as:"the state of one who lacks a usual or socially acceptable amount of money or material possessions."
So, what does it take to be in real poverty in Montana. In 2009, the U.S. Dept of Human Services says that a person is in realitive poverty if that person makes $10,830 or less per year. See http://aspe.hhs.gov/poverty/09poverty.shtml
While the Small Area Income & Poverty Estimates (SAIPE) for 2007 of the U.S. Census Bureau (http://www.census.gov/) - States: The number of all ages in poverty was 131,433 or 14.1% of Montana's overall population. And for Missoula County, the Missoula City-County Health Department and the Healthy Start Council Sept 3, 2008 Missoulian News: "Seventeen percent of all Montana children age 18 and under live in poverty. However, 38 percent of Native American children 18 and under live in poverty in our state. Yet, Native Americans are only 6 percent of our total population. Sixteen percent of children in Missoula County 18 and under live in poverty. Missoula County ranks 20th in the state, which means 36 counties have even more children living in poverty. The lowest rate is 9 percent in Stillwater County and the highest is 33 percent in Roosevelt County. The number of children in extreme poverty - those living at 50 percent of the federal poverty level - is increasing and has reached a statewide level of 8 percent."
So, what does it take in Montana to be labeled indigent? The U.S. Dept of Human Services or the Census Bureau or the U.S. Government have no relative indicators or charts for indigents. Only from the Montana State Code Section 47-1-104(3) of The Public Defender Act, do we get: "An applicant is indigent if: (a) the applicant's gross household income, as defined in 15-30-171, is at or less than 133% of the poverty level set according to the most current federal poverty guidelines updated periodically in the federal register by the United States department of health and human services under the authority of 42 U.S.C. 9902(2); or (b) the disposable income and assets of the applicant and the members of the applicant's household are insufficient to retain competent private counsel without substantial hardship to the applicant or the members of the applicant's household."
Ask yourself, why would Montana's Legislature and Governor choose to use indigent in the Montana Public Defender Act? Will this discrimination provide more poor Montanans with equal access to our Courts or justice? And exactly what percentage of the 14.1% of those stricken by real poverty will the Court or the Public Defender label indigent and actually try to help? Where have the integrity and the dignity in our Legislature & Governor & Courts gone? Really, what social condition is more acute in 2009 than realitive or real poverty?
Remember, the Montana Constitution's Section 4. Individual dignity. "The dignity of the human being is inviolable. No person shall be denied the equal protection of the laws. Neither the state nor any person, firm, corporation, or institution shall discriminate against any person in the exercise of his civil or political rights on account of race, color, sex, culture, social origin or condition, or political or religious ideas."
In the 1972 Montana Constitutional Convention, Delegate Mrs. Mansfield had these comments regarding Section 4 of the Montana Bill of Rights. "The committee unanimously adopted this section with the intent of providing a constitutional impetus for the eradication of public and private discrimination based on race, color, sex, culture, social origin or condition, or political or religious ideas. The provision, quite similar to that of the Puerto Rico declaration of rights, is aimed at prohibiting private as well as public discrimination in civil and political rights....Social origin or condition was included to cover discriminations based on status of income and standard of living."
And also the comment from Delegate Mr. Dahood, "The intent of Section 4 is simply to provide that every individual in the State of Montana, as a citizen of this state, may pursue his inalienable rights without having any shadows cast upon his dignity through unwarranted discrimination...(C)onstitutions are based on the premise that they are presumed to be self-executing, particularly within the Bill of Rights. If the language appears to be prohibitory and mandatory, as this particular section is intended to be, then in that event, the courts in interpreting the particular section are bound by that particular presumption and they must assume, in that situation, that it is self-executing. There was a case in Montana some 60 years ago that involved a provision of our Bill of Rights that had to do with an individual right, and there the Supreme Court said that was self executing and a citizen could enforce it without any type of legislative implementation."
As always, please let me have your comments on this important topic, thanks ...
Labels:
due process,
equal justice,
equality,
indigence,
indigent,
law,
poverty
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)